disruption may occur during the initial perception of the stimulus, at the point of component
encoding, binding, or perhaps during the elaboration or consolidation of the memory units.
Memory and Other Putative Stressors
There is evidence that other sources of stress (noise, threat, thermal conditions, etc.) reduce working
memory performance. For example, several investigations have found that noise increases the
incidence of errors on working memory tasks (Finkelman, Zeitlin, Romoff, Friend, & Brown, 1979;
Gomes, Martinho-Pimenta, & Castelo-Brano, 1999; von Wright & Vauras, 1980). Hockey (1979)
provided a review of the research on the effects of noise on performance and information processing.
He concluded that noise has several effects: 1) it tends to over-arouse an individual, which results in a
speed/accuracy trade-off in performance, 2) it changes attention allocation which reduces working
memory, 3) it creates attentional selectivity or tunneling, 4) it increases response selectivity, and 5) it
tends to reduce a person's confidence in his/her performance. Thus, Hockey viewed the negative
effects of noise on memory as eminating from earlier effects on attention. Evans, Hygge, and
Bullinger (1995; 2000) argued that such effects may be reversible. Wickens, Stokes, Barnett, and
Hyman (1991) studied the effect of various “stressors” (time pressure, noise, and financial risk) on
working memory. They found that these factors tended to worsen memory performance but not for
declarative knowledge tasks. This finding may reflect the resilence of long-term memory despite the
presence of stressful conditions.
Previous investigations into memory performance have found negative effects across a variety of
putative stressors including: fatigue (Davies & Parasuraman, 1982; Eysenck, 1985; Gevins & Smith,
1999; Kleitman, 1963), alcohol intoxication (Gevins & Smith, 1999), simulated military combat
(Lieberman, Bathalon, Falco, Georgelis, Morgan, Niro, & Tharion, 2002), and the thermal stresses of
both heat (Hocking, Silberstein, Lau, Stough, & Roberts, 2001) and cold (Giesbrecht, Arnett, Vela, &
Bristow, 1993). For example, Giesbrecht, Arnett, Vela, and Bristow (1993) found that after immersion
in cold water, tasks requiring minimal cognitive demands remained unaffected (auditory attention,
Benton visual recognition, digit span forward); however, those tasks deemed more cognitively
challenging, requiring work memory (digit span and the Stroop task), showed significantly degraded
performance. Slaven and Windle (1999) devised a unique experimental paradigm—simulating a
disabled submarine. These researchers found that under the stress of cold, there were no significant
performance decrements on measures of working memory. However, self-report measures suggested
that decrements were subjectively perceived. These authors conjectured that motivation, spurred by
the presence of peers, may have played a role in mitigating the effects of the cold. This conclusion is
consistent with the notion that “misery loves company” whereby sharing a negative experience with
others relieves some of the negative effects on the individual. This moderating variable is discussed
further in a later section of the review.
Burrows (2002) examined memory performance under conditions of workload (an increasing list of
words) and time pressure (the speeded presentation of information) measuring the accuracy and
speed of recall on a recognition test. Burrows’ initial experiment was designed by presenting a list of
six words, each word being held visible for two seconds following which it was replaced (on a
computer screen) with the next word. The list of words was presented twice to each subject. During
the subsequent recognition test, subjects were asked to determine as quickly as possible whether the
word appearing was on the previous list or not. Burrows conducted 12 trials, half consisting of target
words previously presented and half consisting of new words. After completing these trials each
subject was asked to rate their subjective stress level and their perceived level of performance (how
well they felt they had done). Burrows then presented a second list of six words instructing the
subjects to add these additional words to the original list. Following a similar 12 trials and subsequent
49